| Presidents Trophy |
| The Presidents’ Trophy is presented to recognize the team compiling the top regular-season point total. |
| Winners |
| 00-01 Rutabaga's Farm Team |
| 01-02 Hawk |
| 02-03 Hawk |
| 03-04 The Wet Beavers |
| 05-06 Blue and White |
| 06-07 Blue and White |
| 07-08 Blue and White |
| 08-09 Johnogrodnick |
| 09-10 Skillzer Revolution |
| 10-11 Blue and White |
| Stanley Cup |
| The Stanley Cup is presented to recognize the team exhibiting supremacy throughout the pool playoffs. |
| Winners |
| 00-01 Rutabaga's Farm Team |
| 01-02 Hawk |
| 02-03 Hawk |
| 03-04 Dee's Jockstraps |
| 05-06 Butterface |
| 06-07 Bad Knees Bears |
| 07-08 Feck |
| 08-09 Johnogrodnick |
| 09-10 Blue and White |
| 10-11 Blue and White |
| Maurice Richard Trophy |
| The Maurice Richard Trophy is presented annually to the leading goal-scoring team during the year. |
| Winners |
| 03-04 Blue and White (230) |
| 05-06 Blue and White and |
| Bad Knees Bears (292) |
| 06-07 Bad Knees Bears (278) |
| 07-08 Bad Knees Bears (289) |
| 08-09 Johnogrodnick (273) |
| 09-10 Butterface (251) |
| 10-11 The Wet Beavers (254) |
| Selke Trophy |
| The Selke Trophy is presented annually to the team with the highest plus/minus during the year. |
| Winners |
| 03-04 Feck (+110) |
| 05-06 Feck (+113) |
| 06-07 Feck (+126) |
| 07-08 Barrie Colts (+104) |
| 08-09 Skillzer Revolution (+102) |
| 09-10 Ashley Schaeffer BMW (+56) |
| 10-11 Finnish Flash (+122) |
| Jack Adams Trophy |
| The Jack Adams Trophy is presented annually to the pool coach adjudged to have contributed the most to his team’s success. (Scored out of 80 points) |
| Winners |
| 05-06 Blue and White (69) |
| 06-07 Blue and White (67) |
| 07-08 The Wet Beavers (63) |
| 08-09 Butterface (74) |
| 09-10 Skillzer Revolution (74) |
| Art Ross Trophy |
| The Art Ross Trophy is presented presented annually to the leading point-getting team during the year (goals + assists). |
| Winners |
| 05-06 Blue and White (708) |
| 06-07 Feck (712) |
| 07-08 Blue and White (702) |
| 08-09 Butterface (693) |
| 09-10 Blue and White (651) |
| 10-11 Skillzer Revolution (669) |
| James Norris Memorial Trophy |
| The James Norris Memorial Trophy is presented presented annually to the team that contains the best four defensemen based on an average of their fantasy points. |
| Winners |
| 05-06 Johnogrodnick (avg. 156.3) |
| 06-07 MBek Nordiques (avg. 157.2) |
| 07-08 The Wet Beavers (avg. 158.3) |
| 08-09 Johnogrodnick (avg. 190.8) |
| 09-10 Johnogrodnick (avg. 151.1) |
| 10-11 Skillzer Revolution (avg. 132.4) |
| Hart Memorial Trophy |
| The Hart Memorial Trophy is presented presented annually to the team that contains the best six forwards, two from each position, based on an average of their fantasy points. |
| Winners |
| 05-06 Puck You (avg. 247.1) |
| 06-07 Jon's Pylons (avg. 246.5) |
| 07-08 The Wet Beavers (avg. 202.5) |
| 08-09 Butterface (avg. 203.5) |
| 09-10 Blue and White (avg. 210.1) |
| 10-11 Blue and White (avg. 190.1) |
| Calder Memorial Trophy |
| The Calder Memorial Trophy is presented presented annually to the team that contains the best rookie based on their fantasy points. |
| Winners |
| 05-06 The Wet Beavers (Ovechkin, 322.5) |
| 06-07 Sean's Admirals (Malkin, 258.2) |
| 07-08 Feck (Kane, 176.1) |
| 08-09 The Wet Beavers (Mason, 252.8) |
| 09-10 North Bay Bears (Howard, 253.6) |
| 10-11 AC T-Rev (Crawford, 217.1) |
| Gryphon Cup |
| The Gryphon Cup is presented to recognize the championship team from the 6 week tournament competed in November and December of each year. |
| Winners |
| 07-08 Blue and White |
| 08-09 Johnogrodnick |
| 09-10 Butterface |
| 10-11 Not Contested |
| Lady Byng Trophy |
| The Lady Byng Trophy is presented annually to the team with the highest number of penalty minutes during the year. |
| Winners |
| 03-04 SuperSaras Newbies (769) |
| 05-06 MBek Nordiques (983) |
| 06-07 MBek Nordiques (793) |
| 07-08 MBek Nordiques (907) |
| 08-09 Blue and White (792) |
| 09-10 MBek Nordiques (767) |
| 10-11 Blue and White (783) |
| Jennings Trophy |
| The Jennings Trophy is presented annually to the team with the highest number of saves during the year. |
| Winners |
| 03-04 Blue and White (4504) |
| 05-06 Bad Knees Bears (4226) |
| 06-07 Blue and White (4548) |
| 07-08 Feck (3918) |
| 08-09 Feck (4670) |
| 09-10 Butterface(4341) |
| 10-11 Finnish Flash (4873) |